Catching Secret Fish in Fish It Roblox is one of the toughest challenges players face. Many assume that high luck boosts, global events, or premium rods guarantee a catch, but the truth is more complex. This guide breaks down why getting Secret Fish is so difficult, how the system actually works, and what you can do to increase your chances efficiently.
Understanding How Secret Fish Work in Fish It
After spending over a week playing nonstop — even AFKing for days — many players, including content creators, discovered that luck alone isn’t the key. Some players with top-tier enchantments and expensive rods still don’t catch any Secret Fish, while others with basic gear manage to pull one after hours of fishing.
The reason lies in how the game calculates randomness. Fish It uses something called RNG (Random Number Generator) — a system that determines random outcomes like critical hits, rare drops, or in this case, rare fish catches.
This means that every cast you make has a small chance to pull a Secret Fish, but it’s not guaranteed, no matter how much luck you stack.
Why Luck Might Be a Myth
Many players believe that “Luck” stats or global luck events drastically increase drop rates. However, in practice, these effects seem minimal. Even during events with +5000 Luck bonuses, some players never caught a Secret Fish after thousands of casts.
One player shared his results after fishing more than 37,000 times — with high-tier enchantments like Leprechaun and Cursed active — and still didn’t get a Secret Fish. Others who spent Robux for VIP or multiplier boosts had similar experiences.
The takeaway: Luck helps, but it doesn’t decide everything.
So What Can You Do to Increase Your RNG?
If RNG determines the chance, your best way to improve results is to fish more often in less time. That’s why Speed is the most important stat in the game when hunting for Secrets. The faster you cast and pull in fish, the more RNG rolls you get — and every roll could be the one that gives you a Secret Fish. Here’s what you can do:
- Use a fast rod like the Astral Rod (43% Speed) instead of slower ones.
- Upgrade your enchantments to include ones that boost casting or retrieval speed.
- AFK fish in high-level zones like the Ancient Jungle to maximize rolls while you’re away.
Remember: catching Secret Fish is all about volume, not just luck.
What About Enchantments?
While enchantments like Leprechaun, Big Hunter, or Cursed sound powerful, they don’t guarantee Secrets. The most effective enchant right now is anything that increases speed or efficiency. Players have tested multiple enchant combinations and found that Reel Speed setups tend to outperform pure Luck setups over long periods.
Does Top-Up or Robux Help?
Another common myth is that spending Robux improves drop chances. Many players who purchased VIP bonuses or exclusive rods found no noticeable improvement. Even YouTubers with full Robux setups caught Secret Fish only after several days of consistent fishing. So while Robux can make the process smoother (faster rods, better bait), it doesn’t directly boost RNG results.
Practical Tips to Catch Secret Fish
Here are the best ways to improve your odds naturally:
- Fish as much as possible — the more you fish, the better your chances.
- Use high-speed rods to maximize attempts per minute.
- Stay active during global events, even if the luck boost feels small.
- Fish in the right zones — Secret Fish often appear in specific high-level areas.
- Be patient — RNG is unpredictable; you might get lucky after 100 casts or 10,000.
In Fish It Roblox, catching a Secret Fish isn’t about luck, Robux, or expensive enchantments — it’s about consistency and persistence. RNG plays the biggest role, so the best strategy is to fish faster and more often. Think of it like a gacha system — every pull is a chance, and the only way to win is to keep trying. Equip your fastest rod, join global events, and don’t give up. Your next cast could be the one that pulls up a Secret Fish.