All Best Bait Recommendation Fisch FischFright Event Guide

The FischFright 2025 Event introduces a brand-new fishing pool called FischFright 2, completely separate from last year’s pool. This pool features 29 unique Fishes, each with specific requirements for bait, season, time of day, and weather.

Some of these fish can also be caught through trick-or-treating or by opening Frightful Crates. If you’re struggling to complete the FischFright 2 bestiary, this guide breaks down exactly how to catch every fish. Check out Fisch Codes for more rewards!

FischFright 2 Fish List and Best Bait to Catch Them

Here’s a quick reference table for all 29 FischFright 2 Fishes, including bait, season, time, weather, and obtainment method:

• Jack-o-Lantern: Gummy Fish Autumn Any Clear Fishing
• Pumpkin Pufferfish :Hallow-Pop Autumn Night Any Fishing
• Frankenshrimp: Candy Corn Autumn Day Foggy Fishing
• Licorice Leech: Gobstopper Autumn Any Rainy Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Candle Carp: Sour Gummy Worm Autumn Night Windy Fishing
• Spooky Relic: Gummy Fish Autumn Day Clear Fishing
• Eerie Relic: Hallow-Pop Autumn Any Any Fishing
• Frightful Relic :Candy Corn Autumn Night Foggy Fishing
• Ghost Minnow: Gobstopper Autumn Day Rainy Fishing
• Mourning Manta: Ray Sour Gummy Worm Autumn Any Windy Fishing
• Caramel Chub: Gummy Fish Autumn Night Clear Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Candy Corn Cod: Hallow-Pop Autumn Day Any Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Frightful Crate: Magnet Any Any Any Fishing
• Xtra: Sour Gummy Pack None Any Any Any Frightful Crate
• Kelpie: Gummy Fish Autumn Any Rainy Fishing
• Phantom Jellyfish: Hallow-Pop Autumn Night Windy Fishing
• Vampire Perch: Candy Corn Autumn Day Clear Fishing
• Spider Salmon: Gobstopper Autumn Any Any Fishing
• Werewolf Walleye: Sour Gummy Worm Autumn Night Foggy Fishing
• Coffin Crab: Gummy Fish Autumn Day Rainy Fishing
• Ectoplasm Eel: Hallow-Pop Autumn Any Windy Fishing
• Potion Perch: Gobstopper Autumn Day Any Fishing
• Gravestone Stingray: Sour Gummy Worm Autumn Any Foggy Fishing
• Marshmallow Mackerel: Gummy Fish Autumn Night Rainy Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Gummy Guppy: Hallow-Pop Autumn Day Windy Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Lollipop Lamprey: Candy Corn Autumn Any Clear Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Baby Nessie: Gobstopper Autumn Night Any Fishing + Trick-or-Treating
• Scarecrow Sour: Gummy Worm Autumn Day Foggy Fishing
• Skeletal Nessie: Gummy Fish Autumn Any Rainy Fishing

Note: Many fish like Licorice Leech, Caramel Chub, and Baby Nessie can be obtained both from fishing and trick-or-treating, while some rare items come from Frightful Crates.

How to Trick-or-Treat for FischFright 2 Fishes

Trick-or-treating is a great way to get fish along with candy. Here’s how it works:

1. Equip your Candy Bucket, which you automatically receive at the start of the event.
2. Head to any of the numbered houses in Crook’s Hollow.
3. Interact with the door to initiate the trick-or-treat process.
4. Depending on RNG, you might receive candy, a fish, or both.

Tip: Check the house rotation often, as each house has a 10-minute cooldown between visits.

How to Reach Crook’s Hollow

Crook’s Hollow is the main hub for FischFright 2. Here, you can:

• Catch all FischFright 2 Fishes
• Complete quests from NPCs like Vlad, the Witch, and others

To reach Crook’s Hollow quickly, use your Frightful Mirror. Simply equip the mirror and teleport to the island to start fishing, trick-or-treating, or completing quests.

Completing the FischFright 2 bestiary takes patience, strategy, and attention to weather, season, and bait requirements. By combining fishing, trick-or-treating, and Frightful Crates, you can efficiently catch all 29 fish. Focus on creating a rotation between fishing pools and houses, and make sure you’re prepared with the right bait and tools. With persistence, your FischFright 2 collection will soon be complete in Fisch.