With the latest events rolling out and Dark Enchantress Cookie already settling into the meta, many players are now facing an important decision. New, returning, and even veteran players are getting access to free Beasts, Ancients, and Legendary Cookies through Dominion of the Beast, Might of the Ancients, and anniversary rewards.
The problem is not getting them, but choosing the right ones. This guide breaks down which Cookies give the best value depending on your progress, so you do not waste these rare picks. Also check out our CRK Codes & Cookie Run Kingdom Tier List for more rewards!
Best Ancient Cookies to Choose First
Ancient Cookies are some of the most important units in Cookie Run Kingdom, especially for early and mid-game players.
Might of the Ancients Part 1 Choice
- Hollyberry,
- Dark Cacao,
- Pure Vanilla.
Pure Vanilla Cookie is the safest and strongest pick here. He remains one of the best healers in the game and works well in story mode, PvE content, and Beast-related stages. His long-term value makes him the top priority, especially if you are new or returning.
Might of the Ancients Part 2 Choice
The second part lets you choose between Golden Cheese and White Lily.
White Lily Cookie is the clear winner. Her damage output, consistency, and overall usefulness outperform Golden Cheese in most modes. Whether awakened or not, she brings strong value and fits into many team setups as a main damage dealer.
Might of the Ancients Part 3 Choice
Once all parts are cleared, you can freely choose one Ancient Cookie.
Hollyberry Cookie is the recommended pick here. Even though her Arena presence has slowed a bit, she is still one of the strongest tanks in the game. With awakening, she provides strong survivability, damage focus, and buffs that help keep your team alive in tough content.
Recommended Ancient order:
- Pure Vanilla
- White Lily
- Hollyberry
Best Beast Cookies From Dominion of the Beast
Beast Cookies are rare and hard to obtain, so free selections matter a lot.
1. Dominion of the Beast Part 1
- Burning Spice
- Mystic Flower.
For new players, Burning Spice is the better option. He works as both a tank and damage dealer, especially when paired with Pure Vanilla. If you already own one of them, always pick the one you are missing since Beast Cookies are difficult to get through gacha.
2. Dominion of the Beast Part 2
- Shadow Milk.
Shadow Milk shines in Arena and Guild Boss battles, offering strong performance and long-term value. He should be your first pick from Part 2 if you do not already have him.
If you already own Shadow Milk, your next choice depends on your focus:
- Eternal Sugar is a better all-rounder and helps smooth overall progression.
- Silent Salt performs better in Arena due to strong Dark and Steel elemental damage.
Quick priority logic:
- Have Shadow Milk and Silent Salt, but no Eternal Sugar: pick Eternal Sugar.
- Have Shadow Milk and Eternal Sugar, but no Silent Salt: pick Silent Salt.
- Missing Shadow Milk: always pick Shadow Milk first.
Which Legendary Cookie Is Worth It?
New players can now get Moonlight Cookie for free after completing newcomer missions following the fifth anniversary. This already covers one strong Legendary DPS.
If you are choosing from the original Legendary Cookies, Sea Fairy Cookie is the best option. She still has solid value in Guild Boss battles, while other older Legendaries are harder to use in the current meta. So in most cases:
- Moonlight is already free
- Sea Fairy is the best Legendary pick if you get a choice chest
With so many free rewards available, choosing the right Cookies can feel overwhelming. The key is focusing on long-term value and versatility rather than personal favorites. Prioritizing Pure Vanilla, White Lily, Hollyberry, Burning Spice, Shadow Milk, and Sea Fairy will give you a strong foundation for story mode, PvE, and competitive content. By making smart picks now, your journey through Cookie Run Kingdom becomes much smoother and far less frustrating later on.